Introduction: Harp Vs. Zone – The Ultimate Approach Disc Showdown
As a disc golfer, you may have heard this common quip before, “drive for show, putt for dough”. That’s all fine and dandy, but it leaves out one of the most crucial parts of the game: approaching. Approaching the basket is its own unique skill requiring tact, touch, and consistency. Throwing good approach shots can save many strokes, especially when using the right approach disc. The Westside Discs Harp and the Discraft Zone are two of the most popular approach discs in the sport. Each make the job of approaching the basket easier on the player. For this Harp VS. Zone showdown, we’ll be addressing what makes these discs so great for approaching, what makes them different from each other, and which one is the right one for you!
Understanding the Basics: What Makes a Popular Approach Disc?
Most players can agree on a few key traits that make up a good approach disc. The first is overstability. You want a disc that consistently fades, and isn’t ever at risk of turning over, even in high-wind situations. After stability comes speed. The type of disc you’ll use to approach the basket can change drastically based on distance and conditions. The most popular approach discs though, are typically in the 4-speed class. 4-speed discs are faster than most putters, but still slower than your typical midrange. The third kay trait is dynamic grip, which is most important for players who throw both backhands and forehands. You want a disc that feels good in the hand for both types of shot.
Harp Vs. Zone: Comparing Flight Paths and Stability
Both the Harp and Zone have all the popular approach disc traits we went over above. Each has consistent overstability, a speed of 4, and great hand-feel for forehands and backhands. They do also differ in a few ways, especially when it comes to flight path and stability.
The Westside Discs Harp tends to have a straighter flight initially, but still a predictable fade. On the other hand, Discraft’s Zone is known for its strong fade and resistance to flipping, even in windy conditions. This gives it a bit more stability throughout the flight. Both discs excel at handling power, but the Zone typically offers a sharper, more aggressive finish, while the Harp provides a slightly smoother, more gradual fade. Depending on your throwing style and the course conditions, one might provide an edge over the other in terms of flight and stability.
Hand-Feel: How the Harp and Zone Differ in Grip and Comfort
Hand-feel is something that often needs direct personal attention. Preference is a key component of comfort, and you as player may strongly prefer the feel of one of these discs over the other. That being said, we can go over the basics of hand-feel differences for the Harp vs. the Zone.
The Harp has a slightly deeper rim and more rounded profile. This gives it a fuller feel in the hand. Many players appreciate this when seeking comfort and a secure grip. The Zone, on the other hand, has a shallower profile. This makes it feel smaller and streamlined in the hand. This can be particularly appealing to players who prefer a quicker, more direct release. The Harp’s depth can provide a bit more confidence for players who like a fuller grip, while the Zone’s shape can allow for more finesse and precision on forehand flicks specifically. Depending on you personal grip preference and hand size, you may like one drastically more than the other even though they’re fairly similar overall!
Durability and Plastics
Both Westside Discs and Discraft have a huge array of plastic blend offerings. Each brand offers unique materials that impact performance and longevity. Plastic preference can really sway the tide as far as Harp vs. Zone goes. The Harp is commonly found in plastics like VIP, Tournament, and BT Hard/Medium/Soft. VIP and Tournament are both premium plastics, which make them extremely durable. The BT blends are baseline, which allows them to beat up faster and have superior grip. Many players carry a premium blend, that will maintain it’s overstable flight, as well as a baseline blend, which will beat up to fly straighter. The same concept applies to the Zone, which is often produced in Discraft’s Z, ESP, and Putter Line blends. Z and ESP are their durable premium blends, while putter line is the softer and less durable option.
Player Preferences Regarding Harp Vs. Zone
As we’ve gone over in this article, even minute differences in discs can polarize golfers’ opinions. Everything from the discs flight path, to its plastic, to its hand-feel can be enough to sway a players preference. Players who choose the Harp typically enjoy its slightly deeper profile, which offers a more comfortable grip for those with larger hands. It also can be preferable for players who are backhand dominant. The Harp’s flight path also appeals to players looking for a disc that flies straighter with a smooth, predictable fade at the end. Additionally, the BT Soft Harp specifically has gained a cult following due to the way its flight-plate puddles in over time, offering a unique feel that players often rave about.
Adversely, players who prefer the Zone are often drawn to its shallower, low-profile design. This allows for a quicker release, especially on forehand flicks. The Zone’s strong overstable nature and more aggressive fade give it an edge for players who need reliability in windy conditions or for those who tend to throw with more power. The Zone’s overstability throughout the flight, combined with its ability to resist flipping even when beat in, makes it a go-to for players seeking consistency on the course. Ultimately, the choice between the harp and the Zone boils down to personal grip preferences, playing style, and the specific demands of the course of conditions.
Harp Vs. Zone – Making the Right Choice for Your Approach Game
Have you decided which approach disc is best suited for you? If not, try them both! More often than not, the best way to find out if a disc is right for you is to throw it yourself. There are also tons of amazing approach discs out there similar in popularity to the Zone and Harp, such as the Innova Toro, the Discmania Tactic, the MVP Entropy, etc. It could be that the right choice for you is to carry both a Harp and a Zone. Many players love the straight, controllable flight of a beat-in baseline Harp, and also see the value in the overstability of a premium Zone. Who’s the winner of the Harp Vs. Zone battle? The world may never know.
I’ll tell you a secret though… I bag Zones.